Skip to main content

Grilled Cheese with Smoky Cheddar

Organic Valley is passionate about food and protecting the food system. Our in-house chefs, product development team members and employee-foodies love finding twists to enhance traditional fare. We also enjoy trying new ways to use organic products to create delectable meals and snacks that you can feel good about sharing with your family.

Organic Valley Flavor Favorites sliced cheese on bread to make a grilled cheese.

Try this classic grilled cheese with a smoky kiss to bring something unique to the table. The Smoky Cheddar provides the right amount of smoke without overpowering or getting lost in the glorious cheddar cheese melt. Tomato soup never had it so good.

5 min Prep8 min Cook13 min Total
5 min Prep8 min Cook13 min Total
4 Servings
Organic Valley Flavor Favorites sliced cheese on bread to make a grilled cheese.
5 min Prep8 min Cook13 min Total
5 min Prep8 min Cook13 min Total
4 Servings

Try this classic grilled cheese with a smoky kiss to bring something unique to the table. The Smoky Cheddar provides the right amount of smoke without overpowering or getting lost in the glorious cheddar cheese melt. Tomato soup never had it so good.

Cooking Mode

Prevent your screen from going dark as you follow along.

Ingredients

Sliced Bread
8 slices sandwich bread

Directions

Preheat: Heat skillet over medium-low heat or set griddle to 300 F.
butter bread: Butter both sides of each slice of bread.
assemble sandwich: Sandwich assembly: 1 slice of bread, 1 slice of smoky cheddar cheese, 1 slice of American cheese then 1 slice of smoky cheddar cheese, 1 slice of bread.
cook: In skillet (or on griddle), place sandwiches and heat for 3-5 minutes then flip and heat other side for 3-5 minutes or until bread is golden or cheese is melted. Tip: Be sure to check every 30 seconds to ensure no burning is occurring. If cheese hasn’t started to melt, cover after flipping.
serve: Remove from skillet, cut in half and enjoy!

Directions

Cooking Mode

Prevent your screen from going dark as you follow along.

Preheat: Heat skillet over medium-low heat or set griddle to 300 F.
butter bread: Butter both sides of each slice of bread.
assemble sandwich: Sandwich assembly: 1 slice of bread, 1 slice of smoky cheddar cheese, 1 slice of American cheese then 1 slice of smoky cheddar cheese, 1 slice of bread.
cook: In skillet (or on griddle), place sandwiches and heat for 3-5 minutes then flip and heat other side for 3-5 minutes or until bread is golden or cheese is melted. Tip: Be sure to check every 30 seconds to ensure no burning is occurring. If cheese hasn’t started to melt, cover after flipping.
serve: Remove from skillet, cut in half and enjoy!

Other Recipes By Organic Valley

Organic Valley Cheesy Stuffed Potatoes
1 hr 55 min

Cheesy Stuffed Potatoes

Get Recipe
Cheese-Stuffed Bacon-Wrapped Hot Dogs
30 min

Cheese-Stuffed Bacon-Wrapped Hot Dogs

Get Recipe
Ghee Fudge
2 hr 20 min

Ghee Fudge

Get Recipe
Organic Valley Eggnog French Toast on a plate with a fork.
10 min

Eggnog French Toast

Get Recipe
Grilled pizza pieces with a bite taken out of it.
30 min

Grilled Pizza

Get Recipe
A man puts bacon and scrambled eggs on cottage cheese bread.
45 min

Cottage Cheese Wrap

Get Recipe
1 /

Similar Recipes

Organic Valley Mac and Cheese made with Flavor Favorites shredded cheese.
1 hr

Homemade Mac and Cheese with Spicy Cheddar

Get Recipe
Cheesy Chicken Bake with Organic Valley Italian Herb Mozzarella Flavor Favorites sliced cheese in a pan.
45 min

Cheesy Chicken Bake with Italian Herb Mozzarella

Get Recipe
Fajita Cheeseburger on a plate with Organic Valley Flavor Favorites Spicy Cheddar sliced cheese.
32 min

Fajita Cheeseburger with Spicy Cheddar

Get Recipe
A skillet of Cheesy Chicken Pasta.
30 min

Creamy Chicken Pasta

Get Recipe
Cheeseburger next to pickles.
20 min

Best Cheeseburger with Special Sauce

Get Recipe
A bowl of homemade mac and cheese with broccoli in it.
35 min

Homemade Mac and Cheese

Get Recipe
1 /