Rootstock Logo
A burger with organic cheese, fresh veggies and the grass-fed beef sits on a counter.


Make a Perfect Cheeseburger Using These 3 Simple Tips From a Chef

I’m here to help you make a mouth-watering burger! Everyone has a different idea of a perfect burger, but we think this homemade burger recipe fits the description. It’s quick, it’s delicious and it’s a must-have at summer cookouts. Check out this easy recipe for the Best Cheeseburger with Special Sauce and three simple tips to prepare and cook a delicious diner-style cheeseburger that your family and friends will love.

We use these tips at my farm-to-table restaurant, The Driftless Café, in Viroqua, Wisconsin.

  • Add 1 tablespoon of Organic Valley Heavy Whipping Cream to 1 pound (16 ounces) of grass-fed ground beef. Trust me, this simple secret ingredient adds depths of flavor and juicy goodness to your everyday homemade burgers. Add salt and a bit of ground pepper, then use your hands to blend and squish everything together. You can make four hamburger patties from 1 pound of beef.
  • Pat the burgers into thin (think “thin to win”) patties to ensure an even and quick cooking time. This not only helps the burgers cook evenly, but also gets food on the table faster! Put the griddle on medium/high heat and place the burger patty. Hear that sizzle? When the beef has golden, crispy edges, give it a flip (about 2 minutes per side). After you flip the burger, cover it with a slice or two of Organic Valley American Cheese and let it get gooey. (Organic Valley vegetarian-friendly American Cheese slices are made with organic butter from pasture-raised cows.)
  • The secret sauce: I know that the combination of ketchup, mustard and mayonnaise isn’t out of this world on paper, but I promise that once you taste them together, you’ll be hooked! Use equal parts ketchup, mustard and mayonnaise. Sometimes it’s the simple things that are best.

This is everything you want in a burger — simple and delicious!

But if you want to go beyond simple, now that you’ve got the perfect burger, let’s dress it up.

The Bun ... Or Not

  • Put a pat of Organic Valley Butter on the griddle. Once melted, put the buns on the griddle face side down to give them a bit of light brown crispiness.
  • Not a fan of buns or prefer gluten-free? Wrap your burger in lettuce or replace the bun with grilled portobello mushrooms.
Packages of Organic Valley cheese slices.

We love Organic Valley cheese slices on burgers.

Topping the Perfect Burger

Staples like red onion, lettuce, tomato, pickles and sautéed mushrooms are great toppings, but cooking a perfect burger when entertaining is also a chance to get creative. Let your guests experiment with their favorites by providing a “topping bar” at your next gathering.

Take a trip to your local farmers’ market to find a multitude of topping ideas, from fresh veggies to home-canned goods like sauerkraut and salsa. Other fun burger toppings:

  • Fried eggs are not only healthy, but a great addition to any cheeseburger.
  • Like a little kick? Top a burger with jalapenos and add pepper jack cheese or go with pickled jalapenos and sprinkle on blue cheese crumbles.
  • Add Swiss cheese, Thousand Island dressing and sauerkraut to create a Reuben burger. Skip the traditional bun and place it on lightly toast rye bread.
  • Cooked crispy bacon or ham deli slices with Muenster cheese.
  • Avocado or guacamole and sprinkle with Organic Valley 3 Cheese Mexican Blend.
  • Onion rings, crispy fried onions or caramelized onions.
  • Potatoes are popular: Some people enjoy hash browns and others prefer french fries on their burger.
  • This is a great time to try Organic Valley's new Flavor Favorites cheesesSpicy Cheddar for a little kick or try Smoky Cheddar which is enhanced with hickory smoked sea salt for a unique flavor profile.
  • Mix and match. Cheese, cheese and more cheese — nothing says only one slice of cheese is needed on the perfect burger.

A delicious, perfect cheeseburger is simple to cook and build to your liking. Whether you prefer just sauce and cheese on your burger, or a stack of endless toppings, do what’s perfect for you.


Man carries a Fajita Cheeseburger with Spicy Cheddar

Fajita Cheeseburger with Organic Valley Spicy Cheddar

Luke Zahm is chef and owner of Driftless Café. He also hosts “Wisconsin Foodie,” an Emmy Award-winning independent television series dedicated to discovering the stories behind the food we eat. Luke and his wife, Ruthie, have a daughter, Ava, and two sons, Benjamin and Silas.

Related Articles

  • Examples of ways to store cheeses including wrapped in foil, plastic wrap and cheese paper.

    The Best Way to Store Cheese to Preserve Flavor and Freshness

    by Alexandra Jones

    Read more
  • An array of cupcakes.

    How to Color Frosting Using Natural Ingredients

    by Rachel Riesgraf

    Read more
  • 4 bowls of ice cream with varying toppings on a wooden table.

    Is Cottage Cheese Ice Cream as Cool as It’s Made Out to Be?

    by Jennifer McBride

    Read more
  • Four varieties of compound butters served on a tray.

    You Have to Try These Breathtaking Compound Butter Recipes

    by Rootstock Editor

    Read more
  • Tim Kline and his horses in the field at his Ohio farm.

    ‘I Truly Want to Save Small Family Farms’

    by Jennifer McBride

    Read more
  • Tags:
  • cooking & entertaining,
  • DIY,
  • meal prep